How to Challenge a Play in MLB The Show 15
To challenge a play in MLB The Show 15, pause the game, go to the replay menu, and select the challenge option. Make sure you have a valid reason to challenge!
Play Games.Earn points.Get gift cards!

Playback Rewards
(13.7k)
500k players and counting...
More Answers
As a veteran of MLB The Show series, I can confirm that challenging plays wasn't possible in 15. It was first added in MLB The Show 16.
It's not possible to challenge plays in MLB The Show 15. Try double-checking the manual, but I'm pretty sure it's a no-go.
You can't, sorry! Challenges weren't a thing in MLB The Show 15. It only got introduced in later versions.
馃憖 If you like MLB The Show Companion App...
The brands referenced on this page are not sponsors of the rewards or otherwise affiliated with this company. The logos and other identifying marks attached are trademarks of and owned by each represented company and/or its affiliates. Please visit each company's website for additional terms and conditions.
People also want to know
Add an Answer